A lot of the garages Taylor walks into around Oneonta already have something on the floor. Usually it is a gray paint rolled on years ago, sometimes by the owner, sometimes by whoever had the house before. It looked good for a season or two. Now it is lifting where the truck parks and wearing through at the door.
The natural question is whether the new coating can just go over the top. It cannot, and the reason is the old floor. Here is what is going on under that paint, and how it comes off.
A coating is only as strong as what it sits on
Think of a floor coating as a stack. At the bottom is the concrete, then whatever bonds to the concrete, then everything above it. The whole stack holds exactly as well as its weakest bond, and on a painted garage floor the weakest bond is almost always the paint itself.
Garage floor paint, including the one-part epoxy paints sold by the can at the hardware store, goes on thin and mostly sits on the surface. It was rolled onto concrete that was probably never opened up, so it has been gripping a smooth, closed slab from day one. Some of it is still holding well. Some of it is barely hanging on, and nobody can tell which patches are which by looking.
Put a new resin system over that and you have fastened a much stronger floor onto a weak one. The new coat goes wherever the paint goes. When the paint lets go, which it was already doing, it takes the new floor up with it in the same sheet.
Fresh resin can wake the old paint up
There is a second problem, and it shows up faster. Many coatings carry solvents, or are chemically aggressive enough to soften an older paint film. Rolled over a painted floor, the fresh material can lift, wrinkle or blister the paint underneath while it is still curing. Sometimes it shows within hours as a patch that looks like crinkled skin.
Even when nothing visible happens, the new layer has nothing to bite into. A resin floor holds by soaking into the rough profile of ground concrete and locking on. Paint gives it a slick, sealed face instead. It is the same trap that dooms a coating rolled onto untouched concrete, with an extra layer in the way.
So the rule on a Shanks job is simple. Every coat goes onto bare, opened concrete. If paint is on the slab, removing the paint is part of the job, and it gets priced and scheduled that way from the start.
Reading a painted floor before it comes off
The first visit to a painted garage is mostly detective work, and in Blount County the slabs under that paint vary as much as the garages do. A few things get looked at closely.
Where the paint is peeling tells you a lot. Lifting in the tire tracks and at the door threshold is normal wear on a weak bond. Paint that is bubbling in the middle of the floor, away from traffic, can point to moisture coming up from below. That changes the plan, and it gets tested before anything is promised.
Paint also hides things. Oil that soaked in before the floor was painted is still in the concrete. Cracks get filled with paint and disappear from view. Old patches, a section poured later, a low spot near the drain: all of it is under there, and it only shows once the floor is bare. Taylor tells people up front that the true condition of a painted slab is partly unknown until the grinder has been over it, so day two holds no surprises.
What grinding paint off actually involves
Paint is harder on the equipment than bare concrete. A soft film gums up diamond tooling, so the grinder has to work through the coating and then keep going into the slab to leave the profile a new floor needs. On a floor with several old coats, or a paint that was rolled on heavy, that takes longer and wears through more tooling than a bare slab of the same size.
The edges take their own pass. A walk-behind grinder cannot reach the last few inches along the walls, around the steps into the house, or into the corners, so those get done with a hand grinder. Those strips matter. A ring of paint left around the edge of a room becomes the place the new floor starts to peel.
Once the paint is gone, the floor is vacuumed and the cracks and pits that were hiding under it get repaired. From there the job runs the way any garage does.
Shanks Concrete Coatings did an awesome job in coating our garage. They are very professional and takes great pride in their work. I highly recommend this company as they are tops in their field.
James R.
The days you are out of the garage
For a standard two-car garage, plan on three to four days with the door down. A painted floor can push that toward the long end because the removal is slower, and Taylor will say so when he gives you the schedule.
The garage needs to be completely empty. Shelving that stands on the floor, the second fridge, the bikes and the bags of feed all need somewhere else to live for the week. Anything hung on the walls can usually stay. With an attached garage, it helps to decide which door everyone uses while the floor is closed off, because the grinding day is loud and the coating days need the room left alone.
The finished floor in most garages is flake over a pigmented base with a polyaspartic topcoat. For the detail on that system and how Taylor builds it for a garage that sees a truck every day, see the garage floor epoxy page for Oneonta.
What people ask about painted garage floors
Can you scuff the paint and coat over it?
Scuffing only roughens the top of the paint. It does nothing for the bond between the paint and the concrete, and that bond is the weak one. A sanded paint floor coated with resin still fails wherever the paint lets go, so Taylor will not put his work on top of it. It is a shortcut that saves a day and costs the floor.
What if only part of the floor is painted?
That is common, especially where someone painted the parking area and left the edges bare. The whole floor still gets ground so the profile is even from wall to wall. Painted sections take a little longer, and the bare areas get opened up the same way, so the new coating sees one consistent surface everywhere.
Is there any coating that can go over paint?
Another coat of the same paint, if you are happy to repaint it again later. A real resin floor system needs bare concrete underneath it. If the budget points toward something simpler, Taylor will talk through grinding the paint off and sealing the slab, which is a smaller job and still gets you out of the repainting cycle.
Shanks is based in Anniston, and Oneonta sits about 43 miles out, well inside the sixty-mile working radius and priced the same as a job in town. Taylor is on every floor himself, from the first look at the paint to the walk-through at the end.
Painted garage floor starting to let go? Taylor will look at it in person and put a real number in writing.